Skill: Critical Strike (Myrmidon) rework

Suggestions the development team does not plan to act on
Post Reply
User avatar
Goliath
Posts: 698
Joined: Wed Nov 24, 2021 10:01 am

Skill: Critical Strike (Myrmidon) rework

Post by Goliath »

Assuming 100% accuracy, and full Combination trees, thee effect of Critical Strike is one of the following:
(The base effect of Combination is a bonus of 0/3/6/9 damage, the bonus averaging at 4.5)
  1. Skipping the first strike, yielding a 0/6/9 nice combination with average bonus of 5 damage
  2. Skipping the second strike, yielding a 0/3/9 nice combination with average bonus of 4 damage (yes, average bonus goes down here)
  3. Repeating the last strike, yielding a 0/3/6/9/9 nice combination with average bonus of 5.4 damage
There's also the possibility of multiple Critical Strikes on a single combination, which make it slightly better, but not much, and muddle the case analysis.
Baseline, Critical Strike improves Combination Attack by roughly a 20% when triggering, or 0.9 bonus damage, due to cases 1 and 2 cancelling each other out. This, combined with the 33% chance to trigger, improves Combination Attack a 6.6%, or by an average bonus of 0.3 damage.

Not assuming 100% accuracy, the effect of Critical Strike improves, as it's uncertain whether you'll be able to access the later effects of the Combination. This makes Critical Strike significantly more attractive at earlier levels, when the Myrmidon's accuracy is low, but a waste of 20 CP later on.
--------------------------------------------------
Replacement suggestions:
Replay
The Myrmidon gets 2 attacks at the final step of the combination, instead of 1.
Dragon's Rage: Instead of removing the reset, possibly increase max combination +1. Alternatively, increase the damage of every combination tier. Alternatively, always start combination at tier 1.

Instinct
X% chance of triggering the maximum combination effect, resetting the combination.

B4 Critical Strike
It was an interesting mechanic, though maybe with reduced bonus and increased chance.
A Parrot with a Blade - Melee/Touchcaster Holy Champion || GrayScimitar - Heavy Sword Tlac IB || RustyWire - Gunwiz
User avatar
Kandarin
Site Admin
Posts: 1340
Joined: Sat Aug 07, 2021 12:10 am
Location: Theater of the Air

Re: Skill: Critical Strike (Myrmidon) rework

Post by Kandarin »

Devs have a plan developed already for rebalancing this.
Katerina Hasheen - Necromancer Advocate, champion of a better Hashaa
Serena Hasheen - Sword Revenant, Freedom Array booster
Isabel Hasheen - Gunwizard Councillor, infusion's #1 fan
Kandarin - Unformed potential, Crusader, fontnet architect
Erduhr-Khazai - Fire-breathing Dragon DO, Evil Overlord, pillager of planes
Post Reply